Why AV Projects in Healthcare Fail (and How to Ensure Clinical Adoption)

You’ve seen it before. The state-of-the-art telehealth cart, purchased with a six-figure budget, sits unplugged in a storage closet. The cutting-edge AV system in the new operating theater goes unused because the surgical team finds it too complex to operate under pressure. The digital rounding boards, meant to streamline communication, are ignored in favor of the familiar whiteboard.

As a healthcare CIO, IT Director, or Facilities Manager, this is a uniquely frustrating scenario. You’ve navigated the complex procurement process, secured the budget, and managed the installation—only to see the technology ignored by the very people it was meant to help. The promised ROI vanishes, and instead of improving patient care, you’ve created “tech clutter” that adds another layer of frustration for burnt-out clinical staff.

Let’s be brutally honest. This isn’t a rare occurrence; it’s the default outcome for many healthcare AV projects. But it doesn’t have to be.

The problem isn’t the technology itself. The problem is a fundamental misunderstanding of the environment it’s being placed into. This article will provide a transparent breakdown of why these projects fail and a practical, repeatable framework to ensure your next one achieves widespread clinical adoption.

The Honest Answer: Why Most Healthcare AV Projects Fail

When a healthcare technology initiative fails to gain traction, it’s rarely for a single reason. It’s usually a combination of critical oversights rooted in treating a hospital like a standard corporate office. A healthcare environment is one of the most complex and demanding settings for any technology deployment.

Here are the primary reasons these projects fall short:

1. Disregarding the Clinical Workflow: Technology is introduced that clashes with the established, time-sensitive processes of patient care.
2. Lack of Clinician Buy-In: The project is driven by administration or IT without involving the end-users—doctors, nurses, and technicians—from the very beginning.
3. Underestimating Infection Control & Physical Realities: Equipment is selected without considering sterilization protocols, physical space constraints, or the harsh 24/7 environment.
4. A Disconnected, “Product-First” Approach: AV is treated as a simple hardware purchase (
   camera + microphone + display

   ) instead of an integrated communication system that must live on a secure network.

5. Forgetting About “Day 2”: The project plan ends at installation, with no realistic strategy for ongoing training, management, and 24/7 support for mission-critical systems.
6. Overlooking Security and Compliance: The solution isn’t designed from the ground up to meet HIPAA requirements and integrate securely with the hospital’s network and EHR systems.

Failure Point #1: Ignoring the Clinical Workflow

In a corporate setting, if a meeting starts five minutes late because of a technology issue, it’s an annoyance. In a clinical setting, five minutes can be the difference in a stroke diagnosis or a critical patient consult. Workflow is everything.

A “workflow” is the sequence of tasks a clinician performs. For example, a nurse’s rounding workflow might involve entering a room, checking vitals, updating the patient’s chart in the EHR, and communicating with the attending physician. If your new telehealth cart requires a complex login, a separate charting application, and takes 90 seconds to boot up, it doesn’t fit the workflow. It disrupts it.

Hypothetical Example: A hospital deployed beautiful, large-screen displays in patient rooms for remote family consultations. But to launch a call, the nurse had to use a consumer-grade remote control, navigate three menu screens, and manually type in a meeting ID. After two weeks of frustration, the nurses defaulted back to using their own iPads—a less secure but far more efficient solution. The expensive, professionally installed system was abandoned because it added 3-4 minutes of “tech time” to a 10-minute patient interaction.

How to Fix It: The solution is not to ask clinicians what they want in a survey. It’s to perform workflow shadowing. Your design team must spend time on the floor, observing rounds, watching procedures, and understanding the rhythm and pressures of the environment. The goal is to design a system that requires minimal change in behavior and integrates seamlessly into the existing sequence of care.

Failure Point #2: “Forgetting” to Get Clinician Buy-In

Clinicians are experiencing record levels of burnout. They are often skeptical of new technology, viewing it not as a tool for help, but as another administrative burden. An IT-led or administration-mandated project that feels “done to them” instead of “designed for them” is doomed from the start.

You cannot force adoption. It must be earned. Without champions on the clinical side who believe in the technology and can vouch for its benefits, your project will face passive resistance and eventual abandonment.

How to Fix It:

• Identify Clinical Champions Early: In the consulting and design phase, not the week before training. Find a tech-savvy surgeon, a respected nurse manager, or a department head who is passionate about solving the problem your AV system addresses.
• Give Them a Seat at the Table: Involve them in product demos and selection. Let them test drive demo units. Their feedback is more valuable than any spec sheet.
• Empower Them to Be Evangelists: When the system is ready, let your clinical champion lead the introduction to their peers. A recommendation from a trusted colleague is infinitely more powerful than a memo from the IT department.

Failure Point #3: Underestimating the Physical & Sanitary Reality

A hospital is not a clean, predictable office park. It’s a chaotic, 24/7 environment filled with specialized equipment, strict regulations, and countless physical and environmental challenges.

Key Considerations Often Missed:

• Infection Control: Can the touchscreen, microphone, and cables withstand repeated cleaning with hospital-grade virucides like cavicide? Consumer-grade plastics will yellow and degrade. Medical-grade hardware is designed with non-porous, sealed surfaces for this exact reason.
• Physical Integration: An operating room may have lead-lined walls that block Wi-Fi signals. A patient room has limited floor space for a large cart. Ceiling-mounted equipment must not interfere with patient lifts or surgical booms.
• Power & Data: Reliable power and data ports are not always conveniently located. Medical-grade power supplies are often required to prevent electrical interference with sensitive patient monitoring equipment.
• Environmental Noise: The ambient noise of a hospital floor—beeping machines, overhead pages, conversations—requires specialized audio processing (like a DSP, or Digital Signal Processor) and targeted microphones to ensure a remote participant can hear the clinician clearly.

A Tale of Two Projects: The Clinical Collaboration Room

This table illustrates how a focus on the clinical reality separates a successful project from a failed one.

The Trade-Offs: A Deliberate Approach vs. A Rushed Implementation

Being brutally honest means acknowledging the trade-offs. The correct, clinician-centric approach takes more time and has a higher initial cost. It’s tempting to take shortcuts, but the long-term consequences are severe.

Your Healthcare AV Project Pre-Flight Checklist

Before you sign a purchase order or approve a design, use this checklist to pressure-test your plan and ensure you are set up for clinical adoption.

• 1. Have you assembled a cross-functional team?

  • Your project team must include more than just IT and Facilities. You need:
    • A Clinical Champion from each primary user group (e.g., nurses, physicians).
    • An Infection Control representative.
    • A Biomedical Engineering team member.
    • A Network Security analyst.

• 2. Have you defined success by a clinical outcome?

  • Shift the goal from “Install 20 telehealth carts” to “Reduce patient wait times for specialist consults by 30%.” The technology is the how, not the what.

• 3. Have you mapped the actual workflow?

  • Has your design partner spent time on the floor observing the technology’s intended use in its real-world environment? Have you accounted for every step, from login to logout?

• 4. Have you asked the hard questions about the hardware?

  • Can every component be cleaned with hospital-grade disinfectants?
  • What is the Ingress Protection (IP) rating against dust and liquids?
  • Is the power supply medical-grade?
  • How does the system connect to the network, and has it been approved by security?

• 5. Do you have a “Day 2” support and training plan?

  • Who does a night-shift nurse call at 3 AM when the system fails?
  • How will you provide ongoing training for new staff?
  • How will software/firmware updates be managed without disrupting patient care?

• 6. Is your budget based on Total Cost of Ownership (TCO)?

  • Your budget must include not just the initial hardware and installation, but also multi-year support agreements, ongoing training, and a budget for eventual replacement parts.

The Bottom Line: Technology Must Serve the Clinician, Not Burden Them

Successful healthcare AV projects are built on a foundation of empathy. They are the result of a deep and obsessive focus on the clinician’s experience, the patient’s needs, and the unforgiving realities of the healthcare environment.

Failure is the default outcome when we treat a hospital room like a boardroom. Success is achieved when we recognize that every piece of technology must be simple, reliable, and secure enough to fade into the background, allowing clinicians to focus on their true mission: patient care. An unused system is always the most expensive one. By investing the time in a deliberate, clinician-centric process, you ensure your technology becomes an indispensable asset rather than a forgotten liability.

Take the First Step Towards Predictable Success

Planning your next clinical technology rollout? Don’t start with a product catalog. Start with a consultation. Simply fill out the form below and we’ll be in touch!